Drawbacks of MACD

Like any oscillator or indicator, the MACD has drawbacks and risks.

  • One of the most significant risks is that a reversal signal can be a false indicator. For instance, the zero-cross image above has a point where the MACD crosses from below and back again in one trading session. If a trader entered a long position when the MACD crossed from below, they would be left with a losing stock if prices continued to fall.
  • MACD does not function well in sideways markets. If prices generally move to the side when they stay within a range between support and resistance. MACD tends to drift toward the zero line because there is no up or down trend—where the moving average works best.
  • Additionally, the MACD zero-cross is a lagging indicator because the price is generally above the previous low before the MACD crosses the line from below. This can cause you to enter a long position later than you might have been able to.

Similar Posts

  • Trading Divergence

    Divergence refers to a situation where factors move away from or are independent of others. With the MACD, it is a situation where price action and momentum are not acting together. For instance, divergence can indicate a period where the price makes successively lower highs, but the MACD histogram shows a succession of higher lows. In…

  • An Overview

    The concept behind the MACD is straightforward. It calculates the difference between a security’s 26-day and 12-day exponential moving averages (EMA). Each moving average uses the closing price of its period (26- and 12-day) to calculate its moving average value. On the MACD chart, a nine-period EMA of the MACD itself is also plotted. This line is called…

  • MACD Histogram

    The MACD histogram is a visual representation of the difference between the MACD and its nine-day EMA—not highs and lows. The histogram is positive when the MACD is above its nine-day EMA and negative when the MACD is below its nine-day EMA. The point on the histogram where momentum is zero is the zero line. If prices…

  • Types of MACD Strategies

    Histogram The MACD histogram can be a useful tool for some traders. While we’ve explained a little bit above about how to read it, here’s how it works. It plots out the difference between the fast MACD line and the signal line. Traders can use the MACD histogram as a momentum indicator to jump ahead of changes in market…